Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Petty

I just received these tonight and I love them. Great quality suede, very comfortable footbed, nice low heel on days I want a break. I got Putty; it's a great neutral. The shoe structure is a little narrow, as compared to the toe on a more rounded, cowboy-style boot. If you're feet are on the wide side, I'd size up a half size. That's what I did and they feel great. I can't wait to wear these shoes with skinny jeans, leggings and skirts.

Fabulous, well made boots! I purchased these in the neutral color - go with everything color! Thank you Sam Edelman for making a boot with a decent sized heel - and comfortable! Thank you Zappos for the quick service! Buy these boots! Don't forget to spray them like you would your Uggs! Ten Stars!

OK--this is my second review of this bootie that I bought over a year ago. When I reviewed it then, I said that it was tight for width but I would see if it would stretch out -- and it did. But it took quite a few hours wearing them. Now, the bootie fits my foot like a glove. This is not a shoe that you want to wear walking out on a cold winter sidewalk (did that - once) for an extended time. You should apply water resist/proof to this. Cushioning is not great, but I broke my foot several years ago. If you want to add cushioned insoles -- I recommend -- go a half size up. Good for driving. Looks great with slacks or jeans and even a skirt. I love how it looks when it's worn in! I've just ordered 4 more pairs of low boots to try out and return the ones I don't want and the black suede version is one. We will see, again. Until Zappos, I've had a really hard time finding nice shoes that fit. Hey other shoe manufacturers out there---More and more women have larger feet! 4 women in my family have 12 and up! I want quality, women's athletic shoes that are made in the USA! I'm not the only one! Hello out there. Are you listening?

These run very small and narrow.

I like the look of these boots. The soles & heels seem well made, but the boot upper is layers & the suede seems sort of thin. They're not a good walking shoe for me - not enough cushioning or support.

Great shoe. A little uncomfortable (not much arch support) but super cute.

I just received these today in the putty color. It is a great neutral that will go with almost everything. I think these run a little narrow, although my feet are on the wide side. I like that the toe is neither too pointed nor too round. Can't wait to wear these as soon the weather cools off.

I really dig these boots. Nice quality construction and soft suede. Cool color too - kind of mossy/olive green. Worried about wearing them in the rain though so I haven't been able to wear them yet. But I'm looking forward to it.

Got this pair in black. Meh. Boring. Bland. Very cute on the web, very blah in real life.

These felt really narrow in the heel, and I have narrow feet. No major complaints about the style but I had to send them back.

Loved the style and price point, didn't like the putty color in person. On the computer screen, the color looked perfect, but when I received the boot, I didn't like it at all. May be better in black.

These boots look good and fit my feet well. Unfortunately the side zipper hurts my foot. Since I plan to wear thin socks with them, I know the zipper will always bother me. So sorry to return.

Based on reviews I ordered a half size up. I couldn't even squeeze my foot in this bootie. Really cute but way too small. Lucky brand & Clark booties fit in my regular size.

Really hard soles, bottom of shoes look really cheaply made. Huge bummer because I love the style and the color and the heel height. Looked great on. But cannot do that to my feet.

Wish I could love them, but I can't as they hurt my feet just to try on! Very sharp looking, but narrow on the toes, the sides of big toes, ouch! And I don't have a wide foot, average width for a narrow foot this shoe is a must have though. I also got the Sam Edelman leopard flats with studs on the toe, those worked!

These really are nice boots and would fit most people well, but the Wide width was not wide enough for my arthritic toe joint. I do like them a lot, but ended up keeping another boot in a 10 instead of my usual 9.5 which fit better. Thanks to Zappos, always, for their great return policy. :)

These are a great shoe. The only thing is that I have a high instep and I’m glad I got a 1/2 size larger to accommodate it.

Love this style! I have over the years purchased just about every color these have come in. Now on my second pair of black. With light weight socks, I can wear these all day long.

Was so happy to find these with a wide width! I'm usually a size 7 and the 7W fit perfectly. the 7.5W slipped off my heel. Great lighter color that can work in every season. I plan to order in more colors!

I purchased these booties in both colors. I wear them daily and always receive compliments. Super comfy and the perfect bootie that goes with everything.

These booties are so cute and go with almost anything from jeans to dresses. I get compliments on them every time I wear them. Very flattering shaft height. I now have them in 3 colors (black suede, putty suede & tan leather.) They run true to size. They were a bit snug in the width at first, but break in after just one to two wears. Some have mentioned that they don't have a cushiony sole, but you could add an insert if you wanted. I can wear them all day with no discomfort. Heel height is also very comfortable. Well made (look like new with 2+ years of wear, so far.)

So happy with this purchase! What a great pair of trendy leopard booties. I love the grey motif. Very comfy.

Toe box is too narrow for my foot.

I love these boots. The leather is buttery soft. I wore them in rain and they cam out looking the same. I usually wear a 7 1/2 or 8. I ordered these in a 7.5. They felt a little bit tight through the instep but good overall. I used a shoe stretcher for just a couple of hours on each boot because the leather is so supple. After that, they were perfect. I love wearing them. They go with everything.

Putting these boots on right out of the box, I was disappointed. I found them difficult to get on and difficult to zip. The leather felt hard and the shoe was uncomfortable, too tight. I was preparing to send them back, looking on Zappos for a replacement. I like the style so much, the next day I put on a pair of medium weight socks and tried the shoes again. This time they were easier to put and zip. I wore them around on the carpet for a while and realized they felt pretty good. I wore them with socks around on the carpet the next day and boy am I glad I did not send them back. I wore the boots for about 5 hours just cooking and doing light chores around the house. They were very comfy, the toe box is roomy enough and I my arches did not ache. The heel height is perfect and the boot did not rub my ankles. They are plain without a lot of embellishment and I like that too. So now after all this, I love the the boot. Can't explain it, don't care. Just know I like them now.