Customer Reviews Naturalizer Olivia

I really wanted this shoe to work. I ordered the grey suede, first time was 8.5 medium width and was too loose on heel. Then I ordered 8 medium width and they were tight and they made a farting sound when I walked. So I tried 8 wide and they squeaked and farted when I walked. Sadly I had to return all three times. Love the style, color, and the suede but would be embarrassed with these sounds going on.

Beautiful silhouette but very uncomfortable from the moment I put it on. Top edge cuts into the top of my foot and construction is stiff.

Man I wish these did not pinch ny feet!! So cute! Love the peep toe. Great price. Had to go back : (

So disappointed. The heel slipped terribly even after insoles and heel cushions. No way to make them work. Returning them today.

I love how they look and they're exactly what I'm looking for, but unfortunately, as what other reviewers said, they slip off when I try to walk in them. I would love to exchange for another size but not sure which size to get. Sadly returning these unless I find a solution to the heel problem.

These tore my heels up (a previous reviewer mentioned this as well). 3 hours of wear at work and I ended up with TERRIBLE blisters. I couldn't ever wear sneakers the next day! It is partially my fault. I need to learn that if the shoes don't feel AMAZING the second they go on my feet, they should not be purchased. They were, however, very cute. That's why I didn't immediately turn them away.

I have wide feet, so I ordered the wide. Actually, I think it was a double wide. Anyhow, couldn't even get my feet in here.

I really wanted to like these shoes. I have been searching endlessly for a nude peep-toe wedge to wear for my wedding in March and I thought I had found the winner. Overall, they are very comfortable for a heeled shoe, and are the simple leather style that I was going for. However, I ordered 4 different sizes in this shoe and none of them fit. I experienced heel slippage with all sizes. My normal size (8M) felt really big and I had almost a 1/2" of space behind my heel. After reading through the other reviews, I ordered three other sizes—an 8N, 7.5M, and 7.5W. Out of all of them, the 7.5W fit the best. However my heel continued to slip, even with heel pads and padded insoles added to the shoe. Unfortunately, it's a design issue. These shoes have so much potential, hopefully they'll be updating the style and correcting the issue.

I was so disappointed in this shoe. I have normally had good luck with Naturalizer but I wore these shoes for 3 hours and I had blisters forming on each heel and one on top of my foot and for most of those 3 hours, I was sitting at my desk. I'm sending them back.

Well, let me start by saying these were worn by someone else and returned because their heel savers were still glued to the heel. Ewwww. I’m not even sure they were the width I ordered because they came in a generic, no label box. Back they go. Can’t keep used shoes.

Keeps slipping off, will exchange for a smaller size and report back!

I've had multiple pairs of similar peep-toe wedges and these are by far the most uncomfortable. I decided to give them a try despite the comments about slipping from other buyers. The first (and only) time I wore them, my heel slipped out three times in the first five minutes. Unfortunately, I was on my way into work and didn’t have extra shoes to change into. I ended up spending the day constantly walking out of the shoes. I’m returning them immediately, which is a shame because the style is nice and the leather is good quality.

Ordered size 8 shoe. Recieved box and it said size 8. But the shoes inside said size 8.5. They were to big! I need size 8. Hopefully I will get size 8. Love the look of these shoes! Thanks

Loved these shoes - perfect nude, not as pink as photo. But unfortunately my heel slipped out when I walk. This is never an issue for me - but I recalled seeing another review with the similar complaint. Too bad, have been looking for a nude shoe for too long.