Customer Reviews Naturalizer Olivia

I had great hopes for the Naturalizer shoe as I needed a comfortable shoe like this for work. I am usually a size 7.5 and ordered this shoe. It was too small so I'm sending it back. I'm not sure if I'll order a bigger size.

Cute, Comfortable. I can see how some say their heel walks out of the back...mine fits decently. True to size, I'm a 10.

Ordered my usual size 7W, and surprisingly it was too big. I had a good 1/2 inch of space behind my heel. Exchanged them for size 6.5W, and they were too tight around the toes. Could not walk comfortably in them for more than 1-2 minutes. I believe these shoes run large and narrow. Unfortunately, I will not be keeping them.

Great looking shoe and overall, it is a good fit. I ordered size 7.5 WW (normal size is 7.5M) due to a recent toe surgery but they are not as wide as I would have expected. The leather is also a bit stiff.

Like many of the other reviewers - this is sadly too large and I'm walking out of it in the heel. Otherwise, they are great shoes and feel comfy. Ordering a half a size down in the hopes that the next ones fit...

Very Cute and comfortable but runs LARGE. My heels kept flipping out of the back of the shoe

Cute shoes. Unfortunately I had to return them as the wide was too narrow and my heel was hanging out of the shoes. I can never find 10.5 WW or 11D in the Naturalizer brand. I hope they will consider adding 10.5 WW and 11D to them collection. Unfortunately, I had to return them.

Overall I am very happy with this shoe. They are very beautiful and a great shade of light tan that's neutral and essentially a nude color for my skin tone. I have a wide foot, and tried both 6.5WW and 7WW, ultimately keeping the 7WW. The toe still pinches slightly, but these are a really soft leather and I know they will loosen over time. My main issue is that I guess since they are WW, the heel area is also built wide, and my heel was slipping out when walking. I added heel pads and now they are OK. As a larger person, I feel more stable in a wedge, and it's also great for taking some pressure off the ball of the foot in a higher heel like this.

I was hoping these had some give for walking. They do not. They were about 1/2 size larger than marked. I wear Narrow, and the narrow size seemed good. Returning.

The heel of the shoe is much wider than than expected. The shoe felt true to size; however, the heel width was way off. I could not take a step with my heels slipping out.

I love these shoes but they are just too narrow on my foot. I have lost a lot of weight since I purchased them and they are still too narrow. Sadly, I have to ship them back!

These were pretty but my heels slipped out and it looked weird seeing two toes

WW width still very narrow. If u have a wide foot these do not give- no stretch. Great style, had to return.

I love these shoes, however the Extra Wide width runs alot narrower than I excpected. I will probably have to return. Wish these were true to size regarding width.

Ordered hoping to replace a pair of well worn Vionic peep toe pumps and was happy to see that this shoe came in a wide width. It seemed like wide meant half-size bigger, because my heel was slipping and my toes weren't peeping. They're going back.

the heel slipped right off my true narrow foot. The overall fit was narrow, just not quite narrow enough for my foot. The shoe was super cute; I so wish it fit!

As others mentioned these shoes run larger and narrower than the size, compared to other Naturalizer pairs that I have. The color was not exactly what I needed so I decided to try other models.

Not for extra wide feet! These open- toed wedges would have been perfect if it wasn't narrow and made my foot look like a sausages.

I ordered a wide. While they fit in the toe box there was a lot of heal slip. They are really cute, sad I'm sending them back.