Customer Reviews Steve Madden Stecy Stiletto Sandal

A warning on the long review ahead, but I hope to address some of the things I looked into (and some I could not find info on) before buying. TL;DR version upfront: I'm very pleased with how these heels look and provide support, but they didn't hold up perfectly after one wear. I diligently read every review I could find online (including those here), and I must start off by clarifying that these heels DO run like Steve Madden typically runs. Thus, if you typically find that Steve Madden runs half a size large on you (and you have to buy a half size smaller than your usual size), then these will also feel too roomy at your typical size. I originally bought a 7 but, after trying them on for sizing at my local department store, I exchanged them for a 6.5. The 6.5 fits PERFECTLY, and I highly recommend going for the size that fits you just snug enough and doesn't gap at the heel when you stand - this type of shoe is so minimal that it has to fit perfectly for walk-ability and stability. The arch support is great for a heel of this height. I owned the Realove (emphasis on the past tense) and, not only were those not as dainty, but the arch was SO dramatically arched that I have no idea how any human foot could stand in them - I couldn't stand wearing them. But the Stecy takes care of that issue wonderfully. I wore them for about 5 hours and they were tolerable by the end. Yes, they hurt eventually, but given that I was walking and standing a lot, I give them props for comfort. Lastly, the strap issue: it is tight, but not uncomfortably so. Just like the footbed sizing is critical, the strap needs to be equally secure so you have as much stability as possible. That being said, I can see how it might be tight for those with wider ankles than mine; however, I did not wear them on the widest hole and I didn't feel pain from having the tight strap. The strap also did not break on me. What DID wear down was the glue on the footbed by the ball of the foot; by the end of the night, the lining was peeling slightly. My foot sweat (not a pretty visual but it is a reality) combined with walking must have melted the glue down a bit, but that's kind of disappointing and a reminder that these are not near the quality of something like Stuart Weitzman. Even though I am a leather fiend and these are NOT real leather (the item information is a bit misleading - zoom in on the photo of the inner heel and you'll see "PU upper"), I found the finish of the "matte" black version to be beautiful and expensive-looking. The all-black upper and sole combo is very chic. Overall, I think the silhouette is beautiful and I believe it is a great, affordable option if you're looking for a minimalist two-strap heel.

These look like the most perfect shoe. So versatile - jeans, dress, whatever! But the toe strap - it was so tight. When I finally shoved my 6.5s in (like an ugly stepsister), the strap hit across the middle of my toes in the strangest place. There was no way I could actually walk. These shoes have very strange proportions. Unless you have the daintiest of feet, like a willowy 10 year old, I don't know how these will fit. I do not wear a wide shoe so just regular ole feet.

Sexy but delicate. Versatile- I plan on wearing this for a black tie event and also with jeans. I usually wear a 6.5 in designer brands and these fit me divinely in a 6. I wouldn't recommend this for people with wider feet or big toes; the toe strap sits closer to the toe edge and feels narrower than usual. A nice alternative would be Steven 'Rykie' which fits looser in general.

Oh my God, I LOVE these shoes! I was concerned, because of some of the reviews that I've read, but don't believe them, this shoe runs true to size. I have wide feet and thick ankles, but that wasn't a problem. They do not run small; They fit perfectly! I love, love, love them!

Sexy and comfortable. Strap across the toes is comfortable and the shoe feels stable. Can't wait to wear them for NYE.

Love these shoes. For stilettos, you know what you're getting in the comfort department, but these were not uncomfortable. I wore these and danced in them all night at a wedding. I definitely recommend.

Ugh, these are super cute but I am in the same boat that most other reviewers are in; my feet aren't super skinny so the strap caused my toes to hang over the sides. If you have really narrow feet (especially toes), then these were probably made for you! They are also uncomfortable to walk in because the platform is so short.

After I ordered the correct size they fit GREAT! Dumb bunny(here) ordered a 9 which is the size i normally wear, so I returned the 9 for an 8 and they are great. The real leather feel and near naked design combined with the ultra light weight make wearing these heels feel like you are barefoot. I wanna say THANK YOU so much Zappo's for the outstanding return policy and super fast shipping of my re-order 5 Star!!! Zappo's WILL BE my first choice for heels from now on.

This is a gorgeous shoe and it goes with almost everything, it’s not the most comfortable. I wear these to weddings and dinners parties (not a lot of walking involved). I would suggest that if you buy these that you have them rubberized. The sole is very slick and walking on hard wood floors can be very dangerous.

Honestly,is super comfy.i definitely recommend it

Beautiful ?? I tried several of this style but they were always too narrow, not these they came in wide and they fit great!! Steve Madden makes such nice shoes and very comfortable!

Love these shoes! They are the perfect summer shoe! I love wearing them with a sequin skirt or long maxi dress. I have also wore them to work and the heel is not too high. I get compliments on them every time I wear them. These are a staple shoe to own.

it was small and narrower

Amazing shoes,looks great on my feet,but not for all day walking.

Super cute and super stylish! My husband loves these and I get compliments every time I wear them out.

These are cute, but aren't very comfortable. The color was also darker than what I was needing.

These were just what I expected and held up great even during a short time in the grass. I never wear wide shoes but had to exchange the regular width for wide because I couldn't get any of my toes under the front strap.

I love them! I want to buy them in every color available!

Wore this to my graduation, it's cute and versatile. I ordered an 8.5 in W and it fits just right.

After reading others' reviews about it being narrow, I ordered a 6.5(WIDE). Very glad I did because they fit perfectly. I've never ordered a WIDE in any shoe before, however my feet may be slightly wider than some - some high heels (in regular width) with a strap across the toes, do feel tight at times but I can usually make them work. Unless you have NARROW feet, the regular will not be comfortable.

Fits true to size. Goes with anythjng. Comfortable and easy to walk in. I have two pairs of these shoes, nude and black. A must have for any wardrobe.

Exactly as photographed. A shoe that goes with everything, simple yet a great statement with the ankle strap. I would buy this again. I only rate the comfort a 4 bc its a high heel and eventually they start hurting after a couple hours of wear, like with any other high heel :)

Nude color is perfect. For as high as this shoe is it is surprisingly comfortable (I rarely wear heels).