Stiction Hiker Waterproof Ice+
Factor Waterproof Thinsulate™
Stiction Hiker Waterproof Ice+
Drover Ice + Waterproof TX
I love these shoes so much. Having said that.. there's clearly a problem with manufacturing because the heel of the first pair I ordered was not attached, so I returned. Replacement pair arrived and the inner cushion was not properly glued to the shoe. Third time's the charm? Hope so... for $120 I'm going to return this pair and ask for a replacement.
Zappos Reviewer on March 13, 2019
These shoes are poorly made -- the heel came apart almost immediately. Also the laces are cute but the leather won't stay tied without knotting.
Zappos Reviewer on March 13, 2019
These boots/shoes are AWESOME!!! I have worn them for a few months and they are now my favorites. I use them mostly as a casual winter shoe, since they look quite nice, and look just like a shoe under long pants. Important note: I am SUPER picky about shoes; the wrong type of support and I cannot wear them. It is hard (nearly impossible) to find shoes that work. Both Caterpillar work boots and these boots have minimal support, which is PERFECT for me. (you can still add your own inserts, but you don't have to fight with existing support). The Arctic Grip is quite good, and are much better in icy conditions than any regular shoe. They have their limits, and don't hold on glaze ice, but I am quite confident in them for snowy/icy conditions. Really, though, they are now my only winter shoes. Comfy, good looks, stable in winter conditions. FIVE STARS!! (plus one for my finicky feet)
Zappos Reviewer from Black Hills, South Dakota on March 12, 2019
These shoes felt super comfortable right out of the box and thanks to the fabric insert have enough room across the widest part of the foot. The very stiff sole is a bit strange, though, and it curves up at the toes. They broke in pretty quickly and I was able to flatten out the curved soles enough to make walking in them feel fine. They are very cute, although the chunky suede laces aren't top my taste and I will probably replace them.
Zappos Reviewer on March 09, 2019
With the Vibram Arctic Grip sole, these boots do help with slipping on wet ice. It's still important to be cautious on ice/snow, though. They are a bit long, but fit well with thick wintery socks. They are waterproof and comfortable for walking in snowy/icy conditions, like for running errands with snowy parking lots, short walks so the dog doesn't get cabin fever, using the snow blower, etc.
Goeasyinthesnow from Bend on March 06, 2019
I’ve worn these once so they aren’t broken in yet, the cushion is great, while the sides are still a little stiff but that’s to be expected. In the four hours I had these on I received too many compliments to count, guys, girls young and old all commented “cute shoes”.
Zappos Reviewer on March 06, 2019
These are so cute! The twead really makes these special.
Meghan on March 03, 2019
These are so darn cute in person. They are definitely an off-white linen look with a bone colored leather. I originally ordered the 9 but they were much to big around the top of shoe opening. The 8.5 is perfect, although thin socks or no socks are a must. The insole is like memory foam. They will be wonderful with bermuda shorts in summer and light weight jeans too. Love, love me some oxfords!
Zappos Reviewer from Queen City on March 02, 2019
The shoes are super cute! I have always been a size 8.5 and with some of the reviews I was thinking of a larger size. I ended up ordering 8.5 and checking the size a few times since the shoes were too big for me. Im not sure if I should try again and order 6.5 or 7.
Zappos Reviewer on February 28, 2019
OMG!! I love me a cute oxford and these are adorable for a spring/summer style and color. they are much lighter in color in person than on the site. The Zappos site makes them look like a 'nude' shade, but they are much closer to bone, off-white...which is fine by me because they are so very cute and incredibly comfortable. The only drawback is that the opening where your foot goes in, is a bit wide, so much so that I cannot tie it tight enough to close the gap. I am going to keep the 9 M, which is my typical size and order an 8.5M, if still available. They are super fun. I am 60 and I love these shoes!!
Zappos Reviewer from Southeast on February 28, 2019
Love these shoes! One can definitely dress them up or down. They feel sturdy with the non slip outsole. Best of all the fit is perfect. I ordered a size 5 1/2 and it fits perfectly. No need to break them in, comfortable right out of the box.
Zappos Reviewer on February 26, 2019
Ordered 1|2 size down. Super cute shoe.
Zappos Reviewer on February 23, 2019
Worst fitting shoe I've ever worn.
Songkane on February 17, 2019
Zappos Reviewer on February 14, 2019
First let me say how impressed I was with the quality of these shoes. The slightly distressed pale blue finish, the heavy but supple pebbled leather of the last. Even the soft leather laces spoke of quality. The toe box is roomy both in depth and across. I generally wear a 9 or a 9.5 and went with a 9.5 because in my experience structured shoes seem to feel a bit tight. In this case, I would wear a 9. There is a cushion under the toe and ball of the foot, and a bit of arch support. I could have used a bit more, but these would fit a dress orthotic easily. Overall, I'm sold on Caterpillar!
Lindley from Modesto on February 09, 2019
Seriously. These are sooo comfortable. And sooo cute. How can such cute shoes be so comfortable? Or such comfortable shoes be so cute. Once winter calms down, I plan to break them in. Ultimately I plan to wear them for my trip to Greece in April. They should be perfect for the tons of walking, uneven surfaces and cute with all outfits. Who knew CAT was such an incredible women’s fashion shoe company too? I absolutely expect them to last a long time and live up to the CAT brand. Time will tell.
Czari from Denver on February 05, 2019
Brought these for my teen as a waterproof shoe. So far, he really likes them - very comfortable and seem true to size. He usually wears an 11 in athletic shoes and the 11 fits. Might run a tiny bit on the big side if anything, but probably no need to size up/down on these. They seem to be well made-time will tell. I hope they truly are waterproof as listed.. will try to update review once we know for sure.
Zappos Reviewer on February 03, 2019
I wear a 10.5 wide and these fit perfectly. The last for Catepillar shoes seems to run consistent with 10.5 rather than a 10. For this I am happy! This is nice casual to work shoe that will be perfect with my teacher outfits. Thanks as always for great service Zappos!
Deb from LaGrande OR on February 01, 2019
I absolutely love these shoes. They are unique and adorable and stylish... unfortunately, a little too big. I am an 8.5/9, and I ordered a 9 because the 8.5 was out of stock. These shoes actually feel very comfortable and because of the laces I don’t think they’d slip (haven’t walked them outside because I might return) and the width is perfect, but there is definitely a good thumb-width extra at the toe. Now the 8.5 is in stock, but the price has gone up; so I’m considering just keeping these. (Also worried that the width on the 8.5 may be too narrow). They are very cute and the color is also what I expected (pale blue and a neutral cream). Love them!
Zappos Reviewer on February 01, 2019
The fit and the size were perfect. The shoe is very comfortable. I have worn them all day at work and I do a lot of walking. These shoes are stylish and they look good with jeans or nice pants. I have never purchased the Caterpillar brand shoes before but I am so satisfied with them that I will definitely be considering this brand again for future purchases.
Eileen from Chicago on January 31, 2019
these boots are very hard to get your foot into with a tight neck opening. gave them away.
Dutch from Drummond Island Mi on January 30, 2019
these boots were a gift for my daughter...she loves them and loves the fit. 9 1/2 just right. even more than that, I LOVE ZAPPOS for the fastest delivery I've experienced. I ordered these late in the afternoon and had them next day! I'm always amazed at your delivery. Thank you again for exceeding my expectations!
Zappos Reviewer on January 23, 2019
These little booties are warm, cute, sassy and very comfortable. I plan on wearing these when I off road in my Jeep....adorable & warm....a win/win!
Tammy from Maysville on January 19, 2019
Nice boot, super comfy, rugged, and pretty darn waterproof from what I can tell. Also, it looks pretty stylish, in my opinion. I recommend it.
Zappos Reviewer on January 15, 2019
I needed new loafers and bought these in brown. I love the tweed accent, and they were incredibly comfortable. However, since I will be mostly wearing them to work, they seemed too casual to keep. They're kind of rustic, even if you were to swap out the suede laces.
Zappos Reviewer on January 12, 2019