Customer Reviews TOMS Majorca Cutout Sandal

I so wanted to love this show and I still do. But with wide feet and less than skinny ankles, this one is not for me. I was barely able to put it on lest zip it up.

Cute shoes but I wear an 8.5 normally (occasionally a 9) and I could barely get these on my feet, not to mention zip them up. They definitely run narrow.

Be specific about your likes and dislikes. How was the fit and size? What does the material feel like? How awesome (or not) do you feel wearing them?

The show was so cute! Strap across toes was tight and hit my foot in wrong place. I have wide boney feet. Could not wear them. They were my favorite pick.

Length was fine. Width was fine. These shoes didn’t fit due to the upper fabric band that crosses the top of my foot. There was no stretch in the material, and so it felt very tight and restrictive when wearing. This also made them hard to slide my foot into when trying them on. Disappointed that this cute style did not work for my feet!

Absolutely love these shoes. They are super comfy and also try to size. However, I am a size 8 with slender feet and ankles, and they feel a bit wide and are lose around ankle. So sadly will be returning.

These shoes are so cute but don’t work for my foot shape. The top panel stops right at the base of my pinky toe bone. I wish they fit better!

The left shoe fit just fine - the right shoe is hurting right under the toes. Since you cannot just get a larger size for one foot, there is not much I can do. I have never had this problem before and I purchase a good amount of shoes from Zappos. Very disappointing.

These did not work for me....too narrow for my size 7M foot and also rather stiff, not sure how comfortable they would be after a few hours..I tried a 1/2 size up but that only increased the length, which I didn't need. Would work better for someone with narrow feet and slim ankles. The style is cute though!

This is a really nice looking shoe and surprisingly comfortable for the heel height. Unfortunately, the top strap digs into the top of my foot when I walk, so that makes it uncomfortable. Maybe the suede material would feel better, but I like the black denim color.

I really liked this shoe style, but I have wide feet and it just didn't work for me. I had to return. If I ordered a larger size, the shoe would have been too long. They were very tight.

I ordered in 7 and 7 1/2 since reviewers said to size up (normally size 7). Size 7 was the right size. Not keeping them though because the front strap rubs on the top of my big toes. Might just be the material (Natural Yard Dye color), so I may try another type. Disappointed because they are very cute and otherwise comfortable.

NOT MEANT FOR WIDE FEET. I have worn Tom's before and find that they are generally more narrow than other brands, but am able to wear and let the fabric stretch out. Not the case for these. I have been waiting so long to buy them after always going out of stock the minute they come back in stock. They're such a great look. I was excited to get them in the mail but my feel feel like little sausages trying to get in these shoes. So sad about it, I was *really* hoping they'd work. I thought about sizing up, but it's really a width thing and not a length thing so not going to bother. Sadly returning these.

These shoes don’t work for those of us that have high arches. Way too tight on the top strap and very uncomfortable. Returned them.

I love the look of these sandals but the ankle cuff is really generous. If you have thinner ankles this sandal will probably be too loose, like it was on me. I tried two sizes, and while the foot pad fit fine, both were too loose in the ankle cuff to be safe to walk in.

Love this shoe but unfortunately I had to return them because they were too loose around my ankles and there's no way to adjust them.

I wanted to love these so badly. Unfortunately, I have a high arch and these didn’t fit well at all. The top strap was much too tight and very comfortable. Returned them right away.

These are super cute, but I find them really uncomfortable. I don't have wide feet, but the front strap over the toes is either too narrow or hits at an odd spot and digs into the side of my feet right at the toe joint. They're okay for just sitting around, but I don't wear them if I'm going to be walking around. I bought them directly from Tom's and didn't get around to returning them, but I wish I did. I've thought about trying to get the front strap stretched out to see if that helps.

I wanted to love them. My first pair the left one was tight so I exchanged them for another size. This time the portion that wrapped from the instep to the ankle was huge!! I returned those. Again, ordered another pair hoping it was just a bad pair- poor fit again. Such a cute style but widely varies as to the sizing.

I loved these shoes but sadly they were too tight around my ankle with no means of adjusting. I had to return them.

Usually I love Toms shoes because they are so comfy but this was not the case with these shoes. The shoe was a bit more narrow. My feet were in pain days after I wore them. I wish I could return them but they've been worn. They felt fine when I was at home though. Oh well, can't win them all

SUPER cute - but I had to return and order a larger size. I'm typically an 8.5 in heals but went with a 9 to be safe - holy moly I could barely get my foot in them! I returned and ordered a 9.5.... hoping the work and I don't have to go for a 10! Also I do have somewhat wide feet, which is part of the reason I'm concerned I might need a 10.

I read other reviews that suggested going up a half size, so I did. They are too big, too loose and the heel cutout seems oddly positioned to me. Ultimately, I don't like them and I'm going to return them.

Had to return. Pretty shoes but the strap across toe box dug into the top of my foot. If you have a more narrow foot may work better for you.

These are just too clunky for summer shoes; however, they're super comfortable. The top strap is bulky if you're a person with a small frame, and they're a bit frumpy looking.