Customer Reviews Cole Haan Jay Grand Cap Oxford

Good looking shoe, I originally bought the regular width, and I, by no means, have very wide feet, but I felt these were too tight especially in the toe box, so I returned it and got the wide version. Wide fits much better and isn't so wide that it ruins the style or anything. It still looks quite slim and very good for a shoe.

Good pair of work dress shoes that are not too fancy. I was worried they were going to take a week to break in but after wearing them around home for 15 minutes for a couple of days before wearing them to work all day they were fine. They broke in easy and they did not have the stiff, blister rubbing your feet red type feeling. Worth the money so far. Let's see how long they last walking around work and NYC.

Got the mahogany color Jay Grands and they look fantastic. Goes great with my slim fit business casual outfits. Looks distinct with blue or khaki. The fit feels pretty good, definitely true to size for my average 9.5 foot sizes. My only gripe is I couldn’t find an exact matching mahogany belt to go with these snazzy shoes. But I’ll keep looking.

Got both colors for my husband and he loves them. They look sharp, and he says they're very comfortable. He prefers the rubber sole over his old leather-soled ones because he has to walk a few downtown blocks to work and they hold up better. We had to get the soles on his old ones replaced about once a year at $70+. Hasn't quite been a year on these but the soles look to be in excellent condition. I wish they made them in Dark Brown. The British Tan is very snazzy, but not as conservative as a basic Dark Brown would be.

Love Cole Haans but unfortunately I had to return those. Not comfortable, cannot imagine being in those for a work day or an evening out. Too hard on the foot, though I think the brand makes the most comfy shoes. I got the large width and even that was tight and scratches every where when i try to walk in them. Also, the darker tip toes is not readily apparent in the pics and not my style. Still think it’s a great brand and the shoe was well made, I was just unlucky this time.

These shoes run slightly large in size, but narrow in width. I had to order a 1/2 size down and the wider width and they fit perfectly. I am in and out of the office frequently and these shoes are the perfect balance of dress and comfort.

Very comfortable and great arch support. I bought these because of my plantar faciitis. Doctor recommended to buy this brand

This shoes are for my 17 year old son, and he really likes them. He thinks the leather feels high quality and that the shoes are very comfortable. He likes the cap toe style and thinks it is more youthful than other styles. I ordered 5 different pairs (love Zappos) and these were the ones he chose. I did have to go down a half size from his usual and that fits great. He is going to wear them to Prom and for any dressy occasions he has.

Fits true to size for other CH shoes I own, incredibly comfortable soles. Soles are synthetic, but with a faux leather stacked-edge look to uphold the classic design. Timeless style so I can wear them forever. Wife said, "You could die in these shoes." Honey, you mean, "I could be buried in these shoes?" Gotta watch my back, I guess.

Great shoe. I wanted a solid all-purpose cap toe and this was perfect. Though it doesn't have the leather outsole of more expensive oxfords/derbys, the Zero Grand outsole and insole very comfortable.

The husband wears a true 8.5 but these were too big and would slip while he walked. We had to order the size 8 which they did not slip but they were not as wide as the 8.5. So he decided to go with the smaller size in hopes that the leather will stretch out.

I'm always on a quest to find dress shoes as comfortable as my Asics Cumulus sneakers, which are my gold standard. A coworker recommended Cole Haans and so far they seem to fit the bill, with a few caveats. I'm normally an 11 in dress shoes, but it looks like I'm a 10.5 in these. And I've never had to order wide shoes before, but these are *very* narrow, so I'd recommend getting the wide version. I'm just starting to wear them, but so far they're pretty comfortable (for dress shoes), and they actually look pretty good. It's very hard to find comfortable shoes that don't look orthopedic, but these look like a win!

Very comfortable shoes, very stylish amd very high quality, than other type of shoes, rubber outsole has perfect traction and durability. At first was dissapointed because they felt hard, but after break-in period they felt excellent and very comfortable.

Look great and when I first wore them inside they were fantastic all round. However, after wearing them for one day they cause pain in my little toes (pinkies). They must be a tighter fit than standard medium width shoes. I have not had this issue with other cole haan shoes, so unsure why this model fits differently than their other shoes. Will update if this gets any better (perhaps these need to be worn more than their other shoes?)

Way too narrow. Could stretch but the style doesn’t lend itself. I ordered a wide and there is no way they are designed for wide feet. Color not true to picture. Much more of a muted yellowish tan than the redder tan shown. Rear of shoe very scratchy and seems like a blister waiting to happen

The most comfortable shoe. Lots of cushion and finally a shoe with a nice size toe box.

My son said this style is more comfortable due to the extra padding around the lip of the shoe and additional inside cushioning.

Great Fit

These Shoes are exactly what I was hoping for. Not too dressy but nice. The fit was perfect. A quality dress shoe for a good price.

Since this is a leather shoe it was kind of uncomfortable at first but after wearing them for a week they are perfect.

Very happy with this shoe. It is a great product.

This shoe was comfortable when I first tried on. The size 7w that I ordered fit perfect. I usually where a 7 1/2 sneaker the either a 7 or 7 1/2 shoe depending on the manufacturer. This is my first Cole Haan shoe. I never had a British Tan colored shoe but needed a change. Very happy with this shoe!!

Great fit, Rey comfortable- worn to wedding

Very comfortable. Big fan!

Excellent