Customer Reviews Calvin Klein Gareth 2

Wow, these shoes look great. But, I ordered a size 9.5 after reading a lot of reviews and seeing that they tend to run large. I normally wear a size 10 or sometimes a 10.5. But the 9.5 is at least a half size too big still, and maybe a full size too big. I'll have to return them and order an 8.5 or 9.

I needed a pair of shoes for my wedding. It can be hard for me to find comfortable shoes (long and narrow feet, and a tendency toward callouses). Took a chance on these, and was thrilled. I had them on for something like 14 hours straight (without breaking them in first!) of standing, sitting, walking, and dancing and my feet only started to complain at the very end. One of the shoes had a minor flaw right in the middle of its gloss finish, but it wasn't big enough to warrant sending the shoes back. In all these are a great-looking, great-wearing shoe. Many reviews say to order a size up or a size down. I took a chance on ordering my exact size and they fit perfectly. (But note that since I have narrow feet, this may mean they run a little narrow.)

One of the most comfortable tuxedo shoes I have ever worn. I recently attended a wedding and danced the entire night. They are great.

I bought these for my 19 year old son to wear for my wedding. He said they were very comfortable although the Vans replaced them 4 hours later! He will wear them again and again!

I got these for my husband to wear to our daughter's wedding. He had purchased another pair but I didn't much care for that style so I went ahead and ordered this pair from Zappos. With free shipping and easy returns I had nothing to lose! He said they were very comfortable as soon as he tried them on and he admitted they looked very sharp. He returned the other pair. He wore them on the day of the wedding from 10am until 3am and said they were great. Need I say more?!

Very comfortable and looked great! Wore them all day and night at my wedding and they were perfect. Order as reviews say. These shoes run a bit large so I ordered 1/2 size down and they fit well.

These are by far the most comfortable dress shoes I have ever worn. After one or two wears the shoes break in and almost feel like slippers. They do run a little big, so size down. I normally wear a 12 but ordered an 11.5. Probably could have even fit into an 11. Will be ordering another pair for backup because I love them so much!

Wore these to my son's wedding. Comfortable all day long. Style is a little on the long side.

They look even better in real. I love the leather of it and it is just a classy shoe.

I was in need of a tux shoe and did not have time to shop around, so I ordered this shoe in hopes it would work for me. I was very pleasantly surprised, the shoe fit great! It was very comfortable from the first night that I wore them. I could not be happier.

Good looking shoe. However, I followed reviewer advice here and ordered a half-size smaller which for my size was wrong - the proper size would have been right. (I ended up going with another brand: Massimo Matteo.)

Nice shoes for a tux. They are fairly comfortable except for the top of the heel, which tends to rub (wear band-aids to break in). The patent leather with a slightly longer toe is stylish but still traditional enough for any formal occasion. A solid value for the money.

If you're looking for a decent pair of black-tie shoes at an excellent price, these are your match! If you are looking for true class, get a pair of Farragamos or Tom Fords, but it's going to cost you!

Very cool looking shoes, bought them for a wedding. Be wary though, they are hard on the hill, they need some breaking in. I was ready to take them off by the end of the night. Also, there are some nails on the sole that, if stepping the wrong way, may make you slip to the ground!

A simple, cheap (compared to other patent leather shoes), reasonably stylish shoe that can be worn with a tuxedo.

For the most part it's a good shoe for the money. I wore them for the first time with my tux & at the end of the night they were a bit uncomfortable; however, jumping around to house of pain may have been the cause.

These shoes look great, especially when you get a nice polish on them. The synthetic is somewhat stiff, even after several months of wear, and the shoes aren't the most comfortable things in the world. The price you pay to look good, I suppose.

These are good looking shoes, look well-made and they're probably comfortable. However, I followed the reviewer's advice here and ordered a half-size smaller. Unfortunately that was wrong for my size and the shoes were too small. One real concern are the 8 nails on the heel (3 + 5). Of those, 3-4 nail heads on each heel that stuck out too far and would scratch any wood flooring. Unfortunate quality issue. Because of the nail heads and my liking the Massimo Matteo shoes so much, I didn't order the correct size.

Very simple styling. Looks good for business or business-casual. Not as comfortable as I would like but I am hoping it gets better with wear. Certainly the look is improving with wear.

These shoes looked good on arrival and were comfortable. However, after half a year they had a hole in the side of the shoe. The leather came away from the sole. I just do not think that should happen after a few months. The Zappos customer service person disagrees and says the shoe's lifespan is only five months. Anyhow, I have never had this happen before so I am attributing it to poor quality in these particular shoes.

Wore them to a wedding, and after one wear realized there were some scratches and gouges on one shoe. And all I did was wear them to a wedding. I know it's not totally beyond repair - I can just get them polished - but for the price, I expected a more durable product.

Very disappointed in fit. Needed tux shoes. Generally 10.5 size. These 10.5 shoes had nearly 2 inches of distance between the end of the toe and the tip of the shoe. 10 may be too small. Just poorly crafted shoe. Buyer beware of true fit.